Last Updated on March 13, 2025
I recently visited the Florida Keys, and the highlights for me were the beaches with crystal-clear waters, awesome sunsets, and of course, the delicious foods with waterfront views.
Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, zesty BBQ, or other dishes, the Florida Keys have it all. Each restaurant offers a unique charm and a taste of island life. Dining in the Florida Keys is a great time!
1. Buzzard’s Roost – Key Largo
The first stop is Buzzard’s Roost as you make your way onto the Keys in Key Largo. It was our first restaurant stop on our road trip from Miami to the Florida Keys.
The Buzzard’s Roost is a top pick for dining in Key Largo. The menu has seafood dishes, including several types of fish, shrimp, oysters, and lobster soup, but also sandwiches and burgers for those not looking for seafood.
Signature Dishes to Try
I had the Lobster Reuben, which was great, and my girlfriend had the chicken sandwich. The yellowtail snapper ceviche is also popular here.
Here, I’m trying the Lobster Rueben at Buzzard’s Roost
Ambiance and Outdoor Seating
The vibe at Buzzard’s Roost is pretty cool and perfect for any occasion. You can eat inside or outside, where you can see the sunset over the water.
It’s great for romantic dinners and family fun. There are lots of boats on the water to see and games for groups to play.
After lunch, we walked back to the dock and saw some pelicans and also a manatee. Can you spot it?
2. Florida Keys Brewing Company in Islamadora
Next up as we make our way through the Keys is the best brewery in the area!
The Florida Keys Brewing Company is a top spot for craft beer fans and food lovers, offering plenty of beer options and even wines and spirts for those who don’t care for beer. There’s also root beer for the kids.
Local Craft Beer Selection
This restaurant has a changing selection of craft beer. You can try different house-made ales and lagers.
Dining Experience Overview
The Florida Keys Brewing Company is perfect for a night out. There’s also a nice outdoor area where you can enjoy the weather, play games such as cornhole and Jenga, and listen to live music.
You can also check out the art and candles at the Islamorada Candle Co located in the back.
Having a local light beer and root beer at Florida Keys Brewing Company
3. Robbie’s Marina – Islamorada
Robbie’s Marina Islamorada is more than a place to eat. It offers unique dining experiences in the Florida Keys.
The atmosphere is fun, with open air market shops selling shells, clothes, and more.
Robbie’s Marina also serves fish or if you go out on one of their fishing charters, you can also have them cook your catch here.
After dinner, you can head to the food truck and grab ice cream or shaved ice. Nearby, they also sell coconut water that you can drink from the coconut.
Activities After Dining
Robbie’s Marina is well-known for the activities here besides dining. Guests can feed tarpon, shop local crafts, and take part in watersports such as fishing and jet-skiing.
We all had fun with our kids feeding the tarpon. Just watch out for the pelicans!
It’s a family-friendly spot where everyone leaves with great memories of the fun.
4. SS Wreck & Galley Grill – Grassy Key
We stayed in Marathon during our recent stop to the Florida Keys, so SS Wreck & Galley Grill in Grassy Key seemed like a good choice for a quick stop along the way.
SS Wreck & Galley Grill in Grassy Key is a top pick for dinner in the Florida Keys.
Must-Try Lunch & Dinner Items
The menu at SS Wreck & Galley Grill has something for everyone. The catch of the day sandwich is a popular pick, along with the Mahi BLT and Wreck’s Burger.
They also feature seafood platters and Cajun Smoked Salmon.
After you’re done dining here, you can check out the Dolphin Research Center, which is next door.
5. Island Fish Co – Marathon
Looking for the freshest seafood? Island Fish Co Marathon is your go-to spot. It’s known for its lively vibe and daily catch menu. You’ll find dishes that mix Caribbean flavors with island twists.
The place is colorful, with decorated walls. It’s a fun place to eat. Try their fresh fish platters or other seafood options, such as oysters and shrimp. There are also steaks, pastas, and lots of other foods to choose from.
Whether inside or outside, you’ll love the meal.
My brother in law got the Philly Cheese Steak and curly fries while I got the fish dinner.
My sister got the shrimp tacos and chips while my girlfriend had the pasta.
This place is perfect for a meal or drink while enjoying waterfront views. It’s especially nice around sunset.
6. Porky’s BBQ – Marathon
Speaking of beautiful sunsets, Porky’s BBQ in Marathon is a top pick among BBQ spots in the Florida Keys.
Porky’s is known for its authentic barbecue, making it a favorite for those who love great flavors in a relaxed setting. It’s also great for those who are looking for something other than seafood in the Keys!
Trying a famous Smokehouse BBQ basket
Best BBQ Dishes and Sides
The menu at Porky’s BBQ is filled with delicious options for BBQ lovers. You’ll find:
Pulled Pork: This dish is tender and juicy, with a rich and smoky taste.
Brisket: It’s sliced perfectly, offering a savory experience with every bite.
Coleslaw: A classic side that adds a creamy and crunchy touch to the BBQ.
Cornbread: Sweet and moist, it’s a perfect match for any BBQ meal.
Porky’s BBQ is a standout among BBQ restaurants in the Florida Keys.
Trying a fish dinner with cheese fries and a Painkiller drink
You have to try the Key Lime Pie when in the Florida Keys!
7. Boondocks Grille & Draft House – Ramrod Key
As you make your way towards Key West, you’ll hit Ramrod Key. Families looking for a great place to eat in the Florida Keys should check out Boondocks Grille in Ramrod Key.
It’s a fun spot with tasty food for all ages. It’s perfect for family dining in the Keys.
Mini Golf
Another thing that’s cool about Boondock’s is the fact that they have an 18-hole mini golf course to play. Bring your family here for some friendly competition after your meal. They also serve drinks and shaved ice to cool off.
8. No Name Pub – Big Pine Key
The No Name Pub Big Pine Key is a top spot among the oldest restaurants in the Florida Keys.
The walls are covered in dollar bills from visitors, and we even put our own dollar bills on the wall here. It’s estimated that there are 65 to 75,000 dollars in one-dollar bills!
We also had their Bloody Mary’s, which are unique because they use wine instead of vodka, but they’re really good!
My sister called it the best Bloody Mary that she’s had.
There are also lots of Small Key Deer in the area, and both times we visited the pub, there were deer right outside the restaurant.
9. Sloppy Joe’s Bar – Key West
Sloppy Joe’s Bar in Key West is a key part of the lively nightlife in the Florida Keys.
It draws visitors with its casual vibe and wide drink selection. As a famous spot in Key West, it’s known for its fun atmosphere, food, and live music.
Guests can try classic bar food with cool cocktails. The place is great for hanging out with friends or meeting new ones.
The Sloppy Joe’s here are a must-try. We also tried the fish and Philly cheesesteak, and those were good.
The downsides are that it gets busy and loud, so it’s not great for little kids, and the food is a bit expensive.
Overall, it’s worth a visit if you’re in Key West. The food and live music are both good, and the restaurant is just a short walk from Mallory Square.
10. Southernmost Beach Cafe & Bar – Key West
The last stop on our tour of restaurants in the Florida Keys is the Southernmost Beach Cafe & Bar in Key West.
It offers a perfect spot for dining with stunning views.
Guests enjoy a mix of beautiful waterfront scenes and great food, making it a memorable place.
Stunning Waterfront Views
We had a few drinks here and spent most of our time at the beach, which is awesome and has amazing views.
While at the Beachfront Cafe, you’re just a block from the landmark buoy that marks you’re just 90 miles from Cuba. Be sure to get your picture taken at this famous spot!
Conclusion
As you can see, the Florida Keys food scene is full of amazing dining spots. You can find everything from laid-back places like Buzzard’s Roost in Key Largo to lively spots like Sloppy Joe’s Bar in Key West.
Most of the restaurants offer waterfront views, and you can also spot wildlife at several of them! I hope you enjoy these Florida Keys restaurants.
Heading to the Florida Keys this year?
Check out our must-have 7 day Florida Keys Itinerary!
Booking a last-minute trip to Florida?
If so, we have you covered. Here are some top recommended tours and experiences!
Top Tours in Florida – Viator
Top Hotels In Florida – Booking.com
Looking To Get Around In Florida?
Check out rental car rates here! 🚗
