Last Updated on June 3, 2023

Always On The Shore contains affiliate links and is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program.  If you make a purchase, we make a small commission at no cost to you. For more information, please read the disclaimer page

If you’re looking for the best restaurants in Anna Maria Island, this list has you covered!  This post covers many of the best places to eat on the island, whether it’s waterfront restaurants, seafood, or just plain ol’ good burger joints.

Anna Maria Island is a barrier island just over an hour south of Tampa.  Many people don’t realize it, but Anna Maria Island actually consists of 3 cities. 

Bradenton Beach is on the southern end of the island, Holmes Beach in the center, and Anna Maria in the northern area.

There are amazing places to eat in all parts of the island and this post will break down many of the best restaurants to try in each city.

Gulf Drive is the main road and offers several great restaurants throughout the island.  Bridge Street is another great area for restaurants, too.

Here are some nice restaurants on Anna Maria Island to try!


Booking a last-minute trip to Anna Maria Island?  

If so, we have you covered.  Here are some top recommended tours and hotels!

Top Tours in Anna Maria Island

Boat Excursion To Capri Island – (Small Group Boat Tour From Sorrento)

Parasailing Adventure – (Above Bradenton Beach & Anna Maria Island)

Private Fishing Trip With Sight Seeing – (Half Day Tour Around Anna Maria Island)

Top Hotels & Accommodations in Anna Maria Island

Playa Esmeralda Boutique Inn – (Top Rated Accommodation In Bradenton Beach)

Bungalow Beach Resort – (Beachfront Property In Bradenton Beach)

Captain’s Quarters At Anna Maria Island – (High Rated Villa With Private Pool)

Anna Maria Island Inn – (Aparthotel Nearby Beach)

Looking To Get Around In Anna Maria Island

Check out rental car rates here! 🚗

Best Restaurants In

Anna Maria Island

Best Restaurants In Anna Maria Island- Bradenton Beach



Best Restaurants In Anna Maria Island- Holmes Beach 



Best Restaurants In Anna Maria Island- Anna Maria 


Is Anna Maria Island Worth Visiting?


With fun activities for the whole family, beautiful Gulf Beaches, and awesome waterfront restaurants, Anna Maria Island is definitely a place worth visiting.


I’ve personally ate at most of these restaurants and I can vouch that the dining experience in Anna Maria Island is top-notch!


Is Anna Maria Island Upscale?


Most of the restaurants on the island are casual dining and you can show up in your flip flops and swimming trunks.  However, there are some good fine dining options here, as well.  I’d say these restaurants are casual upscale and these include:


√ Bridge Street Bistro

√ The Waterfront Restaurant

√ The Feast

√ Blue Marlin Seafood Restaurant

√ Sharky’s Seagrill Restaurant 


Where Do The Locals Eat In Anna Maria Island?


If you’re looking for a true Island experience, then you need to check out where the locals are eating!


√ Rod & Reel Pier

√ Sharky’s Seagrill Restaurant 

√ Minnie’s Beach Cafe



Wrapping Up-

17 Best Restaurants In

Anna Maria Island To Try!



As you can see, Anna Maria Island is home to some of the best restaurants, waterfront spots, and seafood on the Florida Gulf Coast.  


What do you think of this list?  Were there any restaurants that I missed?


If you’re looking for more fun things to do on Florida’s Gulf Coast, check out these 17 amazing beaches!