Last Updated on March 31, 2024

As a well-seasoned Florida traveler and a connoisseur of our beautiful coastal wonders, I get this question a lot: Is Anna Maria Island safe?

Nestled in the Gulf of Mexico, Anna Maria Island is an inviting enclave just off the western coastline of Florida.

A quick hop from cities like Tampa and Sarasota, it is perched up north of Longboat Key and south of Tampa Bay. 

Anna Maria Island stretches over approximately seven miles, with three main sections: Bradenton Beach, Holmes Beach, and the City of Anna Maria.

Each of these areas carries its unique allure, merging seamlessly into a harmonious mix of tranquility and vibrancy. 

It’s a haven that teems with old-world charm, offering visitors a slice of “Old Florida” that’s becoming increasingly elusive in our fast-paced modern world.

Adorned with crystal-clear waters and pristine sandy beaches, the Island also boasts a cornucopia of vibrant wildlife.

But, we’re here to answer an important question: is this picturesque corner of Florida, known for its laid-back vibe and scenic splendors, safe? 

Whether you’re a solo adventurer on a quest for tranquility, a family keen to create precious seaside memories, or a moonlight beach stroller seeking the soothing whispers of the sea, we’ve got you covered.



Beautiful Aerial view at Anna Maria Island





Beautiful sunset in Anna maria Island

Which Parts Of Anna Maria Island Are Safe, Risky?


With its three cities—Anna Maria, Holmes Beach, and Bradenton Beach—the island is generally safe throughout.

However, like any place, it’s not without its share of minor crimes, typically property-related.

As with any vacation, exercise the usual precautions: Lock your car, secure your accommodations, and avoid leaving valuables unattended.



Man surfing in Anna Maria Island



aerial view of the beach in Anna Maria Island



Life guard tower in Anna Maria Island



aerial view of the town and beaches in Anna maria island





Where To Stay In Anna Maria Island


a tropical bungalow house with a splash of colors red and white

Photo Credit – Captain’s Quarters at Anna Maria Island Inn

⭐️ Rating: 8.7/10     📌 Location: 14 8th Street Bradenton Beach   Check Rates Here

Situated in Bradenton Beach, the Captain Quarters at Anna Maria Island Inn features a private pool and easy access to the beach nearby.

This budget-friendly villa offers amenities including a dishwasher, an oven, and a television for your entertainment.



beautiful pool view from the patio of Anna Maria Beach Resort

Photo Credit – Expedia

⭐️ Rating: 9.1/10     📌 Location: 6306 Gulf Dr. Holmes Beach   Check Rates Here

The Anna Maria Beach Resort is a 5-star hotel resort located in Holmes Beach a few km away from Anna Maria Island.

This hotel offers each room a patio and a stunning view of the beach. It also has a large outdoor pool perfect for relaxation.



a cozy living room and bedroom with a beautiful beach view

Photo Credit – Expedia

⭐️ Rating: 9.0/10   📌 Location: 12324 Manatee Avenue West, Bradenton   Check Rates Here

Nestled in Bradenton, FL, the Compass Hotel by Margaritaville Anna Maria Sound features modern and comfortable room accommodations, a beautiful outdoor pool, and a complimentary breakfast.

This hotel also has a bar and restaurant for guests to dine at and enjoy some drinks while enjoying the marina view.



Flock of birds in Anna Maria Island



Always On The Shore contains affiliate links and if you make a purchase, we make a small commission at no cost to you.

For more information, please read the disclaimer page

Booking a last-minute trip to Anna Maria Island?  

If so, we have you covered.  Here are some top recommended tours and hotels!

Top Tours in Anna Maria Island

Boat Excursion To Capri Island – (Small Group Boat Tour From Sorrento)

Parasailing Adventure – (Above Bradenton Beach & Anna Maria Island)

Private Fishing Trip With Sight Seeing – (Half Day Tour Around Anna Maria Island)

Top Hotels & Accommodations in Anna Maria Island

Playa Esmeralda Boutique Inn – (Top Rated Accommodation In Bradenton Beach)

Bungalow Beach Resort – (Beachfront Property In Bradenton Beach)

Captain’s Quarters At Anna Maria Island – (High Rated Villa With Private Pool)

Anna Maria Island Inn – (Aparthotel Nearby Beach)

Looking To Get Around In Anna Maria Island

Check out rental car rates here! 🚗



Travel Resources


Book Your Next Trip!  For Accommodations and short-term rentals, I recommend as they are the best in the business when it comes to rates and places to stay.

To Book Activities- For activities, I suggest booking with Viator, they have thousands of 5-star activities to choose from!

Looking To Start Your Own Travel Blog Or Take Yours To The Next Level? 

Check Out This Free Workshop!I personally joined Scale Your Travel Blog in 2021 and my website has grown exponentially.